My opinion. He did well one world series. Other than that, he hasn't done much. Kind of like AK in his one series. And Eckstein in his WS. Overhype vs Overrated, he would fit in the overrated. IMO.
I always post positive stuff in the vent thread. I just don't like to tread in the polyana thread since I don't like to switch around when Hamilton K's on 3 pitches.