I don't know who brought in Salmon and Finley, but I'm going to guess Nevin did have a role in it. I see Nevin as an "old school" guy and he probably relates to "old school" guys like Salmon and Finley. Finley was a grinder. I think Nevin was a grinder. I don't think it's all that far fetched that he had a role in bringing them in.
As I said earlier - it doesn't really matter who had the idea. The whole organization needs to be evaluated.
Nevin impressed me early on when he seem to have more confidence in his starting pitchers instead of giving them the quick hook. I think it was last year when he had just taken over as the interim manager when he went out to the mound to visit Suarez and most thought he was going to take him out. He didn't. He showed confidence in the player. I liked that.
I'm not saying Nevin is the answer. I'm also not saying he's to blame. I really don't know. A number of factors have led to this team sucking this year - and at the top of the list is injuries. Number 2 is pitching. This team was projected to have good pitching and it didn't materialize. Is it because of the analytics? Coaching? How the stars aligned? I have no idea.
Lots of fans want to assign blame. I don't give a rip. I'd rather they just find solutions. You don't have to assign blame to find solutions.
I've said it before and I'll say it again now. This team has a culture problem. I'm not going to get into that too deep now. Maybe another day.
I've also said this before... it all starts with ownership. Arte has failed, but that doesn't necessarily mean he will continue to fail. He seems to be changing - although slowly, he's been different the last couple years. Can he figure it out? I don't know. All I know is he owns the team and that's out of my control. It is what it is.
I doubt he's happy with how things have played out. I don't believe that all he cares about his revenue. I think he wants to win - he just doesn't know how. Maye he's learning. Time will tell.